SpaceX’s $194 billion share unlock exposes a major risk in Aave’s tokenized stock ambitions

About 1.3 billion SpaceX shares become eligible for sale on Oct. 22, worth roughly $194.3 billion at the Oct. 20 close of $147.89.

A week earlier, Aave Labs proposed accepting tokenized SpaceX shares (SPCXc) as collateral on its V4 Equities Hub on Base. Aave's risk adviser LlamaRisk published its assessment of the listing on Oct. 15 with the largest unlock dated for early November, and SpaceX's earnings date pulled that release forward by about two weeks.

LlamaRisk modeled the earnings-linked release for Nov. 5 to Nov. 9 using third-party earnings estimates.

SpaceX confirmed on Oct. 16 that it would report on Oct. 20, when it posted about $14.6 billion in revenue and $4.4 billion in net income, which places the release on Oct. 22.

In the public thread reviewed as of Oct. 20, the assessment carried the November window, and the original assessment stood as the latest entry.

A smaller release of about 328.4 million shares, worth $48.6 billion at the same price, arrives Oct. 26. The Oct. 22 tranche is 28% of a roughly 4.691 billion-share lockup pool, which adds about 45% to the 2.9043 billion shares already tradable. LlamaRisk's calendar had the larger tranche arriving later and calculated a 40.2% float expansion.

LlamaRisk recommends a 55% collateral factor for SPCXc, below the 65% on Tesla and Meta, the most conservative equities Aave supports.

It also proposes a 6.5% maximum liquidation bonus, a 1,000 basis point collateral risk premium, USDC as the borrowable asset, and a cap of 37,000 SPCXc.

A modeled severe off-hours decline of 41%, a 6.5% liquidation bonus, and about 0.279% of accrued interest over the longest market closure give 0.59 divided by 1.065 times 1.00279, or roughly 0.552.

SpaceX's realized annualized volatility since its IPO is about 81.4%, against roughly 52% for Tesla, and the sample is short enough that LlamaRisk built the tail estimate from other stocks.

The most recent 30 sessions show 51.8%, and the 81.4% includes initial price discovery. The earlier date leaves the haircut formula as written, and the collateral math stands while the event calendar needs an update.

A borrower who deposits $1,000 of SPCXc and borrows $400 of USDC starts at a 40% loan-to-value ratio and reaches the 55% threshold on a 27.3% fall in the share price. At the 55% maximum borrowing level, the position reaches its liquidation threshold.

The haircut protects the lender during liquidation and exposes the borrower to liquidation.

The unlock makes shares eligible to trade, and the size of any selling is unknown. LlamaRisk reports average daily volume of about 91 million shares over 30 sessions.

If 1% of the 1.31 billion shares were sold, that would be 13.1 million shares, about $1.94 billion and 14% of average daily volume. At 5%, the figure is 72% of daily volume, and at 10% it is 144%.