Box 3 starting in 2028: Profits Taxed Only Upon Sale—Except for Crypto?

Crypto holders are waiting for clarity on Box 3. Starting in 2028, stock investors may not have to pay taxes until they sell their shares.

Box 3 starting in 2028: Profits Taxed Only Upon Sale—Except for Crypto?

Starting in 2028, the Netherlands will introduce a capital gains tax in Box 3. Investors will then only pay tax on the profits from their stocks when they sell them, rather than annually on paper gains. This is according to political sources.

For crypto holders, there is one problem: the Box 3 plans make no mention of crypto. Whether Bitcoin investors will eventually receive the same favorable treatment as stock investors remains to be seen in the letter that Finance Minister Eelco Heinen will send to the House of Representatives on Wednesday.

In the plans, the sale rule applies to so-called financial instruments, with stocks and bonds as examples. This is a legally defined category, and direct crypto investments do not fall under it. Furthermore, crypto is not mentioned anywhere in the leaked documents.

In the original bill for the new Box 3, which the House of Representatives passed in February, the general rule for crypto was that annual tax would be levied on capital gains, even without a sale. Only real estate and shares in startups were granted an exception under that bill. No such exception was included for crypto.

The question now is whether the new sales rule will change this situation, or whether crypto—as the only major investment category in Box 3—will continue to be taxed annually on gains that exist only on paper.

Anyone who indirectly owns crypto—through a tracker in a regular investment account—will almost certainly benefit from the change. Such products are financial instruments and therefore follow the rules for stocks. This risks creating a striking disparity: someone who buys a Bitcoin tracker would only pay taxes upon sale, while someone who holds actual Bitcoin on an exchange or in their own wallet may have to pay taxes every year.

There are good reasons to believe that crypto will eventually fall under the same rules as other investments. A separate, more stringent treatment within Box 3 is politically difficult to justify. Moreover, starting this year, crypto exchanges have been providing transaction data to the Tax and Customs Administration in accordance with European regulations. This makes it much easier to levy taxes on actual crypto gains.

Still, there is also a reason why the Dutch government might make an exception for crypto: the cost to the treasury.

According to sources, a complete shift to capital gains tax could cost the government 11 to 25 billion euros. Tax would then only be collected when an investment is actually sold. The more asset categories that remain outside that system, the smaller the budget shortfall.

What is clear, however, is that the plans for Box 3 could have consequences for smaller crypto investors. The government is considering adjustments to the tax-free allowance, which is set at 1,800 euros per year in the current bill. As a result, a larger group of savers and investors may have to pay tax on the returns on their assets.

The adjustment to Box 3 is part of broader political negotiations on the budget. Changes to the new system could cost billions and must therefore be offset elsewhere, as Prime Minister Rob Jetten has previously confirmed.

For crypto holders, the most important factor is what form the new system will ultimately take. The cabinet is still aiming to introduce a tax on actual returns in 2028, but the exact details are still under discussion.

Once the cabinet presents its revised plans, it should become clearer whether crypto will be treated the same way as other investments, or whether different rules will apply to digital currencies.

Originally published by coinnews Aggregated for informational purposes. All rights belong to the original publisher.
← Back to all news