Is Bitcoin Truly “Digital Gold”? 3 Ways the Leading Cryptocurrency Diverges From the Most Popular Inflation Hedge


  • There’s a narrative that says Bitcoin is a great hedge against inflation, like gold.

  • It might be true, but the proof behind the claim is a bit lacking.

  • Bitcoin is differentiated from gold in at least three ways.

  • 10 stocks we like better than Bitcoin ›

Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) is, as you may have heard, often called by the catchy moniker “digital gold.”

But there are a handful of key differences between Bitcoin and real gold, which has long been used as a store of value and as a hedge against inflation. Here are three of the most important ones to know.

For Bitcoin to be an equally good hedge against inflation as buying gold, it needs to maintain its purchasing power in fiat currency over time. That way, as the fiat currency becomes more and more devalued, holders can buy the same amount of goods and services when they decide to convert their coins into fiat.

Consider this chart:

US Consumer Price Index: Purchasing Power Of the Consumer Dollar Chart
US Consumer Price Index: Purchasing Power Of the Consumer Dollar data by YCharts

At first glance, Bitcoin actually looks better than gold over the last five years when it comes to holding value against declining purchasing power denominated in dollars. But this is a bit deceptive.

Gold has been in use as a store of value for thousands of years. Its rarity is well established. If you really wanted, you could make a chart of its value over time that would cover a longer period than any of the fiat currencies that currently exist and can be exchanged for it. And that chart would be ironclad proof that gold is a good inflation hedge, as it literally retains its value to the point at which it outlives many lesser stores of value.

Bitcoin simply doesn’t have that history of use. It only launched in 2009. The idea that it’s worth any serious sum at all is even newer than that. And while its supply is finite — only 21 million coins in total can ever exist — it hasn’t yet outlasted any of the fiat currencies that it’s exchangeable for. So it isn’t proven to protect against purchasing power erosion by inflation, even if in its history so far it has outperformed gold.

An investor considers a smartphone and a couple of notebooks sitting on her desk.
Image source: Getty Images.

Gold is an important metal that’s used in consumer electronics, scientific instruments, jewelry, and even in some foods and liquors, though it isn’t very tasty for those applications. It’s also quite shiny, which, knowing human psychology, makes people want to own it.

But Bitcoin can’t be used for anything except storing value. There’s no industrial process that requires it. It isn’t a component of any physical thing you use. And, being digital, it’s difficult to show off to others.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *